هل من الممكن عزيزى ان نقول
By the time/before I had finished my homework,Ali came.
:078111rg3:

يسعدني ان اكون اول من يرد علي هذه المناقشة الهامة وبالطبع يمكن ذلك اخي الكريم واليك شرح وافٍ ومبسط بالمرفقات كملف word مضغوط

شكرا جزيلا للرائع مستر خالد على هذا الرد الرائع وتاكيدا لهذا الكلام دعنى اكتب الاتى
Before
"Before" as well can either be used with Simple Past or Past Perfect. If the action after "before" is a new action, use Simple Past. If the action after "before" started (and was not completed) before a certain time in the past, use Past Perfect. Compare the following examples:
Example:
Jane had read a lot about elephants before she went to the zoo.
Jane went to the zoo before she had finished reading her new book about elephants.
اليك منى كل احترام وتقدير

شكرا جزيلا للرائع مستر خالد على هذا الرد الرائع وتاكيدا لهذا الكلام دعنى اكتب الاتى
before
"before" as well can either be used with simple past or past perfect. If the action after "before" is a new action, use simple past. If the action after "before" started (and was not completed) before a certain time in the past, use past perfect. Compare the following examples:
Example:
Jane had read a lot about elephants before she went to the zoo.
Jane went to the zoo before she had finished reading her new book about elephants.
اليك منى كل احترام وتقدير
سَلِمَتْ يُمْنَاك استاذي الفاضل

اليك منى كل احنرام وتقدير