جمله من المنهج حيرت الطلاب الفائقين ادخل حلها يابطل
 

But for her, he woudn't have found the cave. (responsibe for)

if he hadtn't responsibe for her , he woudn't havefound the cave (searshed for a cave)

أرجو أن تكون اجابتي صحيحة وان كانت خاطئة أرجو معرفة الاجابة الصحيحة وجزاك الله خيرا

اشكرك على المحاوله ولكن حاولى مره أخرى وسأكتب الاجابه بعد أخذ عدد من المشاركات

She was responsible for finding the cave.

شكرا على المحاوله من الجميع لكنى اريد عدم تغير المعنى ولو تغير طفيف

if he had responsibe for her, he woudn't have found the cave

ويارب الاجابة تكون صحيحة فحين انى مش فاهم حضرتك عايز ايه فى السؤال

She was responsible for guiding him to find the cave.

without his risponsible for her ,he wouldn`t have found the cave

he is risponsible for her so ,he found the cave

برافو هدى ياجماعه الجمله دى موجوده فى قصه THE MASK OF GOLD فى الفصل السابع لما ليلى كانت بتقول Perhaps I was responsible for him finding the cave
انا واخد فكره الجمله من القصه لازم نستفيد من المناهج بتاعتنا

هل انت مدرسه يا هدى؟

she was responsible for why he would have found the cave

Good work
Gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood

She was responsible for his finding the cave


الوحيدة اللي صح
خالص تحياني

She was resposible for him finding the cave.

that is my answer
 

she was responsible for his finding the cave..

شكرا لكم جميعا وطبعا اذكركم ان ال gerund ممكن نضع قبله not فى حاله النغى وممكن نضع قبله صفه ملكيه مثل his وممكن ضمير مفعول مثل him

وراجع قصه The Mask of Gold الفصل السابع صفحه 41 ليلى تقول : Perhaps I was responsible for him finding the cave

اللى حل الجمله ب his او him finding الخ اجابته صحيحه