سؤال محيرنى

[selectedone]

فى الوحدة الاولى فى المحادثة
Have you finished

,وفى التدريبات موجودة بصيغة اخرى
Are you finished


الصح الجملة الاولى ام الثانية ؟؟؟ وشكراً

[a_2007]

Both are right
the first sentence is present perfect
Have+subject+p.p?
the second sentences is present simple
are+subject+adjective?

[memomando]

Both questions are right,but Have you finished? is more polite.While Are you finished? is used commonly among friends

[ام نور ويوسف]

الاولى هى الصح وانا كمان فكرت فى نفس الكلام لانها التانية صفة ولا علاقة لها بانتهاء الفعل والله اعلم

[نايف مهاب المصرى]

I'd like to tell anyone who is not specialized in English , shouldn't give his opinion . Secondly , to remind you that the book is American and is no longer being taught there now due to being old and not coping with the modern age , taken and adapted by two careless ladies for the Egyptians , not caring for our customs and our examples , our priors and habits ....and so on , they just changed some kind of clothes and names .
concerning the question
are you finished?
slang american
have you finished ?
is the right one but the other one is right for the americans and not for the language

[selectedone]

I'd like to thank all friends who participated