سؤال هام لمدرسى اللغة الانجليزية

[الثورة المصرية]

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
ارجو من مدرسى اللغة الانجليزية الرد السريع على هذا السؤال

هل يجوز ان يبقى زمن الجملة فى الماضى البسيط بدلا من الماضى التام عند التحويل الى الكلام الغير مباشر

ali said "I get up late
ali said that he got up late.

.ali said that he had got up late

[fareslove]

yes
yes yes yes

[الحواتى]

.ali said that he gets up late

[Nabil kamal Iskander]

نعم بمكن أن يظل الماضى البسيط واليك أمثله توضيحيه مختلفه :

She said to her brother, “I phoned you yesterday
She told her brother she phoned him yesterday
He said to me, “I sent the letter two days ago”

He told me he had sent the letter two days before / two days earlier.

¨ He said to me, "I didn't see the robbers last night."

He told me he hadn't seen the robbers the night before / the previous night.

¨

[محسن دومه]

yes, of course

[miss rasha reda]

you had to study for your next exam

correct)

[Mr. Sayed Ouf]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة miss rasha reda

you had to study for your next exam

correct)

You will have to study for your next exam.

[nahralhob]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة nabil kamal iskander

نعم بمكن أن يظل الماضى البسيط واليك أمثله توضيحيه مختلفه :

she said to her brother, “i phoned you yesterday
she told her brother she phoned him yesterday
he said to me, “i sent the letter two days ago”

he told me he had sent the letter two days before / two days earlier.

¨ he said to me, "i didn't see the robbers last night."

he told me he hadn't seen the robbers the night before / the previous night.

¨

عندى سؤال
لو الجملة ف المضارع التام المستمر عند التحويل يحول الى الماضى التام المستمر ولا الى الماضى التام
وارجو الافادة

[mr eteacher]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة الحواتى

.ali said that he gets up late

Ali says ( that ) he gets up late


or


Ali said ( that ) he got up late

[mr eteacher]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة Mr. Sayed Ouf

You will have to study for your next exam.

You have to study for your next exam