لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
The school (which / where) Iattended has only one classroom.

يعنى اية حضرتك عاوز الترجمة علشان بس افهم سؤال حضرتك

ولا اختار من اللى بين الاقواس

[quote=نبيل موريس جورج;1149853]لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
Choose
The school(which / where) I attended has only one classroom.

Where هى الادق

the answer is where

where لانattendفعل متعدى فى هذه الجملة

for example the flat where i live has 3 rooms

لكن the party which i attended was crowded

the school has one classroom . i attended in it .
so i can say to link them together :
the schhol where i attended , has one classroom
we replace ( in it ) by the relative pronoun where
as it refers to place

The answer is where because it describes the place I attend in it definitely
Best wishes

شاكر لكل من شارك لكن الجملة دي كويسة انا حليتها where اول ما جاءتلي لكن دلوقتي اميل الي which ايه رايكم

me too I think both of them are correct
if we regarded school as a building ,we can use'where'
but if we rgarded school as a curriculum=course I think we can use 'which'
(the same with the word( class)

me too I think both of them are correct
if we regarded school as a building ,we can use'where'
but if we rgarded school as a curriculum=course I think we can use 'which'
(the same with the word( class)


I agree with you, sir
both are right

think (which) is better than where as u describe the school as a building consisting of one classroom . despite the idea of attending .

me too I think both of them are correct
if we regarded school as a building ,we can use'where'
but if we rgarded school as a curriculum=course I think we can use 'which'
(the same with the word( class)
اتفق مع الزميل العزيز
و ان كنت اميل اكثر الى where
و يمكن استخدام which فى حالة وجود حرف الجر in

The correct answer is "Which" because the verb attend is followed by the place without preposition.
I attend school. correct
I attend in school. incorrect
the relative pronoun "where" must replace a place adverb not an object. In other words the pronoun where replaces a preposition + noun or the word "there"

the best answer for this sentence is
The school which I attended
because teh question doesn't talk about school as a place here

لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
The school (which / where) I attended has only one classroom.


The original two sentences are:
The school has one classroom . I attended in it .
where refers to the place I attend in it
but if we regard to school as a course. the classroom is a place and doesn't`keep in step with a course.
SO
The best answer is (Where)

I think the best answer is of course
{ where } because we refer to it as aplace when we say has one class

يا حونا attend لايأتى بعدها حرف جر أبدا
I can't say "attend in school

In my opinion the best answer to this sentence is which not wheras we
don't use preposition with attend

I think that the correct answer should b" which I attend Because school here i referred to as a thing like a course it is not refered to a s a place .What makes this opinion more probable is using the verb attend not go

الادق where لان الجملة تتحدث عن المدرسة المكان

The answer is where because it describes the place I attend in it definitely

شاكر للجميع علي المررو ولكن اعتقد الاجابة which هي الاجابة الصحيحة

which هي الاجابة الصحيحة

Dear Mr. Nabil
I think the correct answer is WHICH not where
In your example "SCHOOL" is the direct object of the verb ATTEND
We say: attend the funeral / class / a meeting ....etc.
We also say: Which school do your children attend? -
- The school which my children attend is called Al Fustat
Here is An Easy Test to decide whether to use WHICH or WHERE
Use the word replaced by the relative pronoun after the verb that comes after it
1. If that word requires an adverb particle "e.g. in, on, at, under, below ....etc. before it, then it refers to place or position. In this case we must use WHERE
Example
The place (which / where) he was born is Tanta.
Note: He was born in this place./ in Tanta / in it
Here the correct answer is "WHERE"
2. If that word does not require an adverb particle, it is a direct object of the verb preceding it. In this case we have to use WHICH
Example
The place (which / where) we visited last week was fascinating
Note: We visited that place. We visited it
In this case we are using `place` as mere object. So we must use "WHICH or THAT"
BEST REGARDS

The right answer is beyond doubt 'which'. If you are not sure look in the following link
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/The_school_that_Winton_Churchill_attended

The answer is where

the answer is where because it refers tothe place

رجا ءمن الا سا تذة المشرفين ارسال دليل المعلم للصف الاول الثا نوي الجديد mohamed_ghay13@yahoo.com

I think where is the best choice as it refers to a place & the school is a place

الحل الصحيح هو where لعدم وجود حرف جـــــــــر

If we answer it by sense I think it is WHICH

الاجابة اصلا ما تنفعش الا where ولو كان فيه in كانت الاجابة هتكون which

لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
The school (which / where) Iattended has only one classroom.

The school in which I attended has only one classroom
The school which I attended in has only one classroom
The school where I attended has only one classroom

لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
The school (which / where) I attended has only one classroom



which
I think is the only possible answer , as attend is like visit = have no prepositions and only used after : which
REGARDS
:redface:

Hi, thanks for care. As far as I am concerned, I think the most definite answers are:

- The school where I attended .......
But we can also say: - The school which I attended in ........

Of course the answer is where not which
The sentence says the school .. I attended has one classroom.
so it is a place not anything else

Look at these sentences and compare
The house which I bought has three rooms.
The house where I live has three rooms.

Hi everybody ,many great thanks for every body here,your efforts and your answers are splendid ,but,we should know the difference between:(which) and (where) :We use (which) after any place to show the discription of it.Let me elicitate the example above :The house which I bought has three rooms.this example shows the discription of the place.When we use (where) after any place ,we point out that place we work or live in regularly.(ATTEND) WITH PLACE MEANS GO THERE REGULARLY So the answer will be (where) as you go there regularly .you may work there or study there.Thanks for eveyone

REMEMBER: We use (where) after any place to show the purpose of it not to describe it.

فى اللغة الانجليزية تحل which محل المكان فى حالتين
اولا لو ارتبطت which بحرف جر او تم فصل حرف الجر عنها مع وجوده فى الجملة والجميع متفق على تلك الحالة

I went to the library where I read a very good book
I went to the library in which I read a very good book
I went to the library which I read a very good book in.
2- ثم نأتى للحالة الثانية وفى هذه الحالة لو تبعت جملة الوصل بالفعل مباشرة يجب أن تستخدم which ( لتشير للمكان كفاعل ) لانها فى هذه الحالة تحل محل الفاعل ( المكان ) بمعنى أن where لا يمكن أن تحل محل الفاعل هنا فنستخدم

which
لتقوم بعملها
...
ولو لاحظنا هنا سنجد اننا نتكلم عن المكان كشيء وليس كمكان ايضا لذلك سيفسرها البعض انها من حيث المعنى أقوى ولكنها قاعدة واضحة فى ضمائر الوصل
1- فى حالة وجود حرف الجر فى الجملة سواء سبقت بحرف الجر أو تم فصل حرف الجر عنها
They demolished the old house which was about to collapse

يا جماعة لو هانختار where هاتكون الجملة كدة
the school where I attended a course has only.........

الكلمة Iattended مش ليها أصل فى القاموس فلو سمحت تحط جمل ترجمتها مفهومة

كل اللى جاوبو مش فاهمين معنى الجملة ايه فلو سمحوا اللى جاوبوا يوضحولى معنى Iattended او ترجمة الجملة بأكملها

كل اللى جاوبو مش فاهمين معنى الجملة ايه فلو سمحوا اللى جاوبوا يوضحولى معنى Iattended او ترجمة الجملة بأكملهاملحوظة هى I attended;)

ملحوظة هى I attended;)

معنى I attended درست فيها- حضرت دروسي فيها

Hi everybody ,many great thanks for every body here,your efforts and your answers are splendid ,but,we should know the difference between:(which) and (where) :We use (which) after any place to show the discription of it.Let me elicitate the example above :The house which I bought has three rooms.this example shows the discription of the place.When we use (where) after any place ,we point out that place we work or live in regularly.(ATTEND) WITH PLACE MEANS GO THERE REGULARLY So the answer will be (where) as you go there regularly .you may work there or study there.Thanks for eveyone


دي تعريفات نظرية ضيفي لها إن where لازم يكون بعدها حرف جر محذوف

الإجابة which لأن attend مبتخدش حرف جر
و زي ما قلت لحضراتكم :
which
I think is the only possible answer , as attend is like visit = have no prepositions and only used after : which

REGARDS
:redface:

Sorry my dear friends
But I insist on Where
You can see here
http://www.usingenglish.com/quizzes/answers.php?id=373

Good morning everyone .My dear colleagues when I say the answer is (where) not (which),I intend to point out to focus on (attend). Please Mr.ABDELHADY ,Don't tackle the subject on one side, your answer should be based on all meaning and all words.You and with many presisted in having preposition with (which) or (attend) that's wrong ;so your answers are dipped down.I said before: ATTEND WITH PLACES MEANS :GO TO THIS PLACE REGULARLY (EVERY DAY),THAT MEANS YOU WORK OR STUDY OR.....ETC(YOU GO THERE FOR THE PURPOSE OF THAT PLACE).TO SUM UP WE CAN SAY THAT(WHERE) IS USED TO ILLUSTRATE THE PURPOSE OF THE PLACE.(WHICH) IS USED TO SHOW THE DISCRIPTION OF THE PLACE.REMEMBER (WHERE=IN WHICH=WHICH...IN) SO THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THEM.
ENJOY YOUR TIME.
Mr.HATEM ATTIA.MY E.MAIL IS:hatem_attia99***********

My E.Mail again to be circulated is:hatem_attia99***********. please every one, consult oxford english dictionary to know the meaning of attend.THANKS FOR ALL.

يا حونا attend لايأتى بعدها حرف جر أبدا
I can't say "attend in school

In my opinion the best answer to this sentence is which not wheras we
don't use preposition with attend

I think that the correct answer should b" which I attend Because school here i referred to as a thing like a course it is not refered to a s a place .What makes this opinion more probable is using the verb attend not go

شاكر للجميع علي المررو ولكن اعتقد الاجابة which هي الاجابة الصحيحة

Dear Mr. Nabil
I think the correct answer is WHICH not where
In your example "SCHOOL" is the direct object of the verb ATTEND
We say: attend the funeral / class / a meeting ....etc.
We also say: Which school do your children attend? -
- The school which my children attend is called Al Fustat
Here is An Easy Test to decide whether to use WHICH or WHERE
Use the word replaced by the relative pronoun after the verb that comes after it
1. If that word requires an adverb particle "e.g. in, on, at, under, below ....etc. before it, then it refers to place or position. In this case we must use WHERE
Example
The place (which / where) he was born is Tanta.
Note: He was born in this place./ in Tanta / in it
Here the correct answer is "WHERE"
2. If that word does not require an adverb particle, it is a direct object of the verb preceding it. In this case we have to use WHICH
Example
The place (which / where) we visited last week was fascinating
Note: We visited that place. We visited it
In this case we are using `place` as mere object. So we must use "WHICH or THAT"
BEST REGARDS


The right answer is beyond doubt 'which'. If you are not sure look in the following link
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/The_school_that_Winton_Churchill_attended

which
I think is the only possible answer , as attend is like visit = have no prepositions and only used after : which
REGARDS
:redface:
اتفق مع اراء الاساتذه
الحل هنا which لاننا مش بنتكلم على المدرسه كمكان
و لان الفعل attend لا نستخدم معه حرف جر

I never know why you are at a loss.Attend has a preposition (to) as (phr v);so when you say attend never takes preposititon is wrong.At last not least we can say that more than twice Place with (where) refers to the purpose of it, but place with (which )refers to the discription of it . What I want to say for all;don't hustel after the idol rule of which or where ; your answer key with (attend). please everybody ,try to cosult the dictionary to know the meaning of attend with place.Best wishes for all .MR.HATEM ATTIA

مع احترامى للجميع
الحل where
الاخوة اللى قالوا attend لا تأخذ حرف جر غير صحيح لانها تاخذ العديد وفى المثال السابق تاخذ at
لان ما بعدها يصف one classroom
They attended at the University of Pennsylvania.
لو كان يصف المدرسة كمنهج فلا تاخذ حرف جر
They attended college together
وبجمع المثالين
They attended college together at the University of Pennsylvania.


شكرا

the best answer is which

attend isn't followed by a preposition.
The sentence : I attended a school..........
NOt : I attended in a school.

الاجابة يا سيدى العزيز هى where لاننا نقصد المكان اما اذا كانتالاجابة which فلا بد من وجود حرف جر معها فنقول the school in (at) which I attended هذا وبالله التوفيق

This is my first impression and I will do more search soon: the correct answer is" where". We are talking about the school as a place. We are not referring to any courses here. Also, the word " classroom" confirms what I believe.

The answer is where

معذرة لكل المشاركين الحل which وليس where لا الصحيح ان نقول
(..I attend (a cl ass a school a party a coures بدون حرف جر in ويمكن الرجوع لقاموس oxford

انا مضطر اغلق الموضوع يا جماعة للاسف مافيش حد عايز يقتنع رغم ان المثال عادي جدا ومش يستاهل كل دة وبصراحة بألاقي اراء غريبة جدا وغلط يحاول اصحابة بكل الطرق ان يبدوا صحيحا اعتقد ان الجميع ادلى بدلوه هنا ويكفى هذا ولنتناقش فى جمل اخرى تستحق هذا النقاش