لماذا يعتبر هذا هو الحل الصحيح

[مستر طارق فؤاد]

It really pleases me that you have this discussion.


Let me take you to another one that I had with a colleage:

I set the following sentence on the monthly school test:
He took a taxi. It was not necessary to do so. (Use : have)

Will you use: didn't have to , needn't have, or both are right?
I'm waiting for you opinions

[ينابيع الحب]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة tarekfouad

it really pleases me that you have this discussion.

let me take you to another one that i had with a colleage:

i set the following sentence on the monthly school test:
he took a taxi. It was not necessary to do so. (use : Have)

will you use: didn't have to , needn't have, or both are right?

i'm waiting for you opinions

.as he did the action the answer is:need'thave

[مستر/ عصام الجاويش]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة tarekfouad

It really pleases me that you have this discussion.

Let me take you to another one that I had with a colleage:

I set the following sentence on the monthly school test:
He took a taxi. It was not necessary to do so. (Use : have)

Will you use: didn't have to , needn't have, or both are right?

I'm waiting for you opinions

طبعا الاجابه هى :
He needn't have taken a taxi

ليه بقى ؟

عشان needn't have + pp بنستخدمها لما نحب نقول : لم يكن من الضرورى ان يفعل شيئ فى الماضى بس

هو عمله !

اما didn't have to + inf. بنستخدمها لما نعوز نقول : لم يكن من الضرورى ان يفعل شيئ فى الماضى وعشان

كده ماعملوش

( طبعا الشرح ده عشان نبسط بس الموضوع لابنائنا الطلاب الذين سيدخلون على هذا الموضوع مش للاخوه المدرسين فهم يعرفون هذا الكلام اكثر منى )

والله شيئ يسعدنا جميعا ان نتناقش فى المنهج باسلوب هادئ ونستفيد من تلك المناقشات ولكن الفت نظر

بعض احبابى ان كتاب الوزاره ليس كتاب مقدس ووارد ان يكون به اخطاء

[Egyknight]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة tarekfouad

It really pleases me that you have this discussion.

Let me take you to another one that I had with a colleage:

I set the following sentence on the monthly school test:
He took a taxi. It was not necessary to do so. (Use : have)

Will you use: didn't have to , needn't have, or both are right?

I'm waiting for you opinions

needn't have is the right answer
Best regards