ارجو دخول كل مدرسى اللغه الانجليزيه للنقاش فى هذه الجمل

[نبيل موريس جورج]

ده رد منقول من محرر long man واتمني الفائده للجميع وتحياتي للرائع مستر عصام

These answers are based on The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language and the corpus-based Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English.

Each one is syntactically singular and would usually take a singular pronoun in a tag question. Thus, if the sentence were
Each one of the boys is absent, isn’t he? or Each one of the apples is rotten, isn’t it? there would be no problem of agreement.

A problem arises because in modern English there is a strong tendency to avoid what is seen as ***ist language. Many people no longer see he as a ***-neutral pronoun.

The pronoun they has been used with a singular meaning since Middle English and is commonly used this way in informal language. However, many people still avoid such use in formal language.

Tag questions are more common in informal language than formal, so therefore, if I had to choose between these two, I would choose the second one: Each one of them is absent, aren’t they?

But in real life I don’t think I would say such a sentence to begin with. I would be more likely to say They’re all absent, aren’t they? and thus avoid the whole issue of agreement.

[مستر/ عصام الجاويش]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة نبيل موريس جورج

ده رد منقول من محرر long man واتمني الفائده للجميع وتحياتي للرائع مستر عصام

These answers are based on The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language and the corpus-based Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English.

Each one is syntactically singular and would usually take a singular pronoun in a tag question. Thus, if the sentence were
Each one of the boys is absent, isn’t he? or Each one of the apples is rotten, isn’t it? there would be no problem of agreement.

A problem arises because in modern English there is a strong tendency to avoid what is seen as ***ist language. Many people no longer see he as a ***-neutral pronoun.

The pronoun they has been used with a singular meaning since Middle English and is commonly used this way in informal language. However, many people still avoid such use in formal language.

Tag questions are more common in informal language than formal, so therefore, if I had to choose between these two, I would choose the second one: Each one of them is absent, aren’t they?

But in real life I don’t think I would say such a sentence to begin with. I would be more likely to say They’re all absent, aren’t they? and thus avoid the whole issue of agreement.

يامستر انت اللى رائع بجد صراحه انت افدتنى جدا بهذه المعلومات القيمه
يعنى انا عن نفسى اللغه عندى تزوق وعشان كد انا حاسس ان الافضل انى اقول Each one is happy, aren't they
ياريت كمان يامستر تدخل على الموقع وتجيب الفرق بين could و was able to
وطبعا اوجه شكرى لكل الاخوه الذين دخلوا وابدوا ارائهم القيمه